For most collectors, an Unlimited Base Set Charmander is not worth grading unless it can earn PSA 9 or PSA 10. A 1st Edition Charmander in superb condition is the main exception because high-grade sales reach four figures. Grading means hiring a service to authenticate a card and assign a condition score from 1 to 10. Charmander #46 is a Common Base-set card illustrated by Mitsuhiro Arita, so edition and condition decide the outcome.
Table of Contents
- Which Charmander Do You Have?
- What Does PSA 10 Require?
- What Does Grading Cost and Take?
- When Does The Math Work?
Which Charmander Do You Have?
Your card falls into one of three Base Set groups: Unlimited, Shadowless, or 1st Edition #46. MyDex TCG identifies Charmander #46 as a Common Base-set card released Jan. 9, 1999.
That common status keeps most ungraded copies cheap. Check the edition before you spend money on grading. Unlimited copies trade at low ungraded prices. First Edition and truly superb copies face a different calculation.
What Does PSA 10 Require?
PSA defines GEM-MT 10 as virtually perfect with four sharp corners, sharp focus, full gloss, and no staining, as explained in PSA grading standards. Centering must fall around 55/45 to 60/40.
CardTrack reports high supply for Shadowless Charmander, with 12,170 graded copies and 1,445 PSA 10s for a 12% gem rate. Off-center, soft-corner, or played copies should stay ungraded.
What Does Grading Cost and Take?
PSA charges $59.99 per card under its Standard tier for cards valued up to $1,000, according to PSA's new Standard service level. That tier estimates 90-100 business days for turnaround.
That fee and wait set a high bar for a Common card. You pay upfront and wait months before you can sell. The grade must add more than the fee.
When Does The Math Work?
Trading Card Trends via PriceCharting valued Unlimited Charmander at about $2.60 ungraded versus $66 in PSA 9 and $352 in PSA 10, as shown in the weekly Base Set price snapshot. CardCodex modeling puts the after-fee return near +$29.57 for PSA 9 and -$7.05 for PSA 8.
PokemonPrice reports about 957 PSA 10 copies of 1999 Base Set 1st Edition Charmander #46, with eBay sales of $1,113 and $1,200 in fall 2024, detailed in the 1st Edition sales history. Use this screen before submitting:.
- send only centered copies with sharp corners and full gloss
- keep Unlimited copies raw unless PSA 9 looks likely
- reserve grading for 1st Edition or superb Shadowless copies
- leave played or off-center copies in a binder
You Might Also Like
- Is My Tyranitar Pokemon Card Worth Grading?
- Is My Squirtle Pokemon Card Worth Grading?
- Is My Ninetales Pokemon Card Worth Grading?