Your Ninetales is worth grading only if it is a clean vintage holo with a real shot at a top grade. Grading means paying a company to authenticate the card, score its condition and seal it, and that cost beats most modern or worn cards. Vintage holos can jump in value once sealed at the top grade. Most played copies and nearly all modern copies stay below submission cost.
Table of Contents
- Why does the payoff sit at the top grade?
- How hard is Gem Mint 10?
- What will submission cost?
- Should modern Ninetales stay raw?
Why does the payoff sit at the top grade?
According to PriceCharting's current market table, Base Set Ninetales #12 recently traded around $15.76 raw versus about $2,093.60 in PSA 10 PriceCharting Base Set sales. That spread leaves little reward for mid grades. Only a near-perfect copy captures the premium.
PSA CardFacts lists Expedition Ninetales-Holo #21 with only 73 PSA 10 copies and a $2,240.21 PSA-10 value. Low surviving supply supports the high-end price. Sellers need that scarcity plus a top-grade result.
How hard is Gem Mint 10?
CardTrack reports 479 PSA 10s among 21,437 graded Base Ninetales #12 copies, a 2.2% historical rate as of 6 Nov 2026 CardTrack Base Ninetales population. Most submissions miss the grade that pays.
Buyers should expect an 8 or 9. PSA Grading Standards define Gem Mint 10 as virtually perfect with four sharp corners, full gloss, no staining and centering near 55/45 on front and 75/25 on back PSA grading standards. Pre-screen in strong light before you pay a fee.
- Check front and back centering; printing fixes it
- Check each corner for whitening or softness
- Check edges, surface gloss and stains
- Skip cards with one soft corner or dull gloss
What will submission cost?
PSA's official trading-card pricing lists Value at $39.99 and Standard at $59.99 per card, plus shipping and higher tiers for valuable cards PSA trading-card grading prices. A valuable vintage Ninetales can move into a higher tier. Add shipping both ways.
CGC Cards Services and Fees offers a cheaper path for low-value cards. Its Bulk tier charges $17 per card with a 25-card minimum and $500 maximum value. Its Economy tier charges $20 per card with a $1,000 maximum value.
Should modern Ninetales stay raw?
CardTrack valued modern Ninetales Sword and Shield #23 at $0.44 raw with a $30 estimated PSA-10 value as of 2 Nov 2026. A single grading fee can exceed the finished-card value.
Bulk CGC pricing helps only when you already have 25 eligible cards. Keep clean modern copies raw, binder-stored or lot-listed. Reserve your grading budget for a centered vintage holo with sharp corners and clean gloss.
You Might Also Like
- Is My Tyranitar Pokemon Card Worth Grading?
- Is My Articuno Pokemon Card Worth Grading?
- Is My Alakazam Pokemon Card Worth Grading?