Your Blastoise is worth grading — paying for a sealed 1-to-10 condition score — only if it is a valuable printing in near-perfect shape. Most worn, Unlimited, or modern copies are worth more ungraded. The gap comes from edition and grade risk. A true Gem Mint 10 can multiply value by a large amount, while an 8 or 9 often adds little after fees.
Table of Contents
Which Blastoise printings pay?
Edition decides the math. Polkastarter reports 2026 Goldin sales of a 1999 Base Set Blastoise #2/102 in PSA 10 for $73,810 and $138,880, against about $1,370 ungraded, in Polkastarter's Blastoise price roundup. Later printings show far smaller jumps, with Shadowless and Unlimited examples rising from a few hundred dollars raw to thousands in PSA 10.
Unlimited still has a clear winner-take-all curve. PriceCharting's live board lists Unlimited Base Set Blastoise #2 at about $108 ungraded, $9,375 in PSA 10, $12,188 in BGS 10, and $2,363 in CGC 10 Pristine, according to PriceCharting's Unlimited Blastoise board. Only the top grades capture the premium.
What does a 10 require?
PSA calls Gem Mint 10 virtually perfect. The card needs four sharp corners, sharp focus, full gloss, and no staining, with front centering near 55/45 and back centering near 75/25, under PSA's grading standards.
That standard rules out most binder cards. Light edge whitening, soft corners, print lines on the holo, or off-center borders drop a card to 9 or lower. Check centering, corners, surface, and edges in bright light before you decide.
What does grading cost?
PSA raised Value Bulk and Value prices in February 2026, and folded TCG Bulk and Value Bulk into one Collectors Club-only Value Bulk tier, according to PSA Staff. The sticker fee is only part of the bill.
CardPreGrading puts the all-in cost near $35 to $45 after return shipping, insurance, and outbound postage, so raw cards under $20 seldom recover the fee even as 10s, in CardPreGrading's grading guide. Add the wait and the risk of a lower grade.
Should you send yours?
Send only cards that pass a strict pre-grade filter. CardPreGrading suggests submitting when expected post-fee gain tops about three times cost, often raw value above $50 with strong centering, sharp corners, clean holo, and no edge whitening.
Most cards return PSA 8 or 9, and a 9 often fails to cover fees on common cards such as 2023 Scarlet and Violet 151 ex, cited near $124 raw against $510 in PSA 10. If yours fails any check, keep it raw and save the fee.
- Raw value above $50 with a real PSA 10 comp
- Centering near 55/45, four sharp corners
- Clean holo with full gloss and no whitening
- Expected gain above three times all-in cost
You Might Also Like
- Is My Charizard Pokemon Card Worth Grading?
- Which Silver Tempest Pokemon Cards Are Worth Grading?
- Which Pokemon GO Pokemon Cards Are Worth Grading?