To avoid buying a stolen graded Pokemon card, check its certification number against PSA's stolen-item list before you pay. Then buy through a seller or platform that verifies the slab and offers a clear return policy. A graded card is a card authenticated, graded for condition, and sealed in a clear holder with a label.
On October 13, 2026, multiple customer orders were stolen from a FedEx truck after pickup at PSA's Santa Ana, California facility, according to PSA's theft update. Those cards can now appear in resale listings. A quick number check protects both your money and the original owner.
Table of Contents
- Check the stolen-card list first
- Verify the slab after you receive it
- Buy where the card gets checked
- Spot a risky listing
- Report a possible stolen card
Check the stolen-card list first
PSA published the complete list of all 6,451 stolen items with PSA certification numbers and serial numbers for serialized cards. PSA says buyers can check a slab before paying.
PSA also says it deactivated the certification numbers for every stolen graded item. Ask the seller for a clear photo of the front label before you agree to buy. Compare the certification number and any serial number against the stolen-item list.
- Get the number from the lower right of the label
- Match every digit and serial number exactly
- Do not pay if the seller refuses a clear label photo
- Do not pay if the number appears on the stolen list
Verify the slab after you receive it
PSA tells buyers to verify every PSA and PSA/DNA certification number in its online form after receipt, using the number in the lower right of the label or sticker, according to PSA's cert verification page. Make this check part of receiving the card. Keep the card sealed while you check it.
Verification has limits. PSA warns that verification does not remove counterfeit risk because criminals copy real certification numbers from public sources onto fake inserts and documents. So match the physical slab, label print, holder seal, and card against the verification record. Treat a mismatch in grade, card description, or photo as a stop signal.
Buy where the card gets checked
eBay routes eligible single graded trading cards valued at $200 and above through PSA authentication, according to eBay's authenticity guarantee page. Graded cards receive slab and label verification only, with no regrading. That step gives buyers a practical stolen-or-fake checkpoint.
Prefer reputable retailers, auction houses, and platforms that monitor for the stolen items. PSA says it shared the stolen-item list with marketplace sellers, auction houses, and digital commerce platforms. Require a clear written return policy before payment.
Spot a risky listing
The U.S. Office of the Comptroller of the Currency advises buyers to purchase only from reputable retailers and treat unusually low prices as likely fraud. A deal far below recent sales for the same card and grade is a warning sign.
Poor photos, rushed sales pressure, and missing certification numbers add risk. Use these checks before sending money: Walk away when one or more signs appear. Another copy will appear from a clearer seller.
- Seller will not show the full certification number
- Price is far below market with no clear reason
- Listing uses stock photos instead of the actual slab
- Seller refuses returns or uses only irreversible payment
Report a possible stolen card
Both the Santa Ana Police Department and the FBI are investigating the theft. PSA says it provided video footage, shipment manifests, and item-level records. PSA directs tips to the FBI's Los Angeles office.
Save the listing, seller name, label photos, certification number, and messages. Report retail fraud to the FTC at ReportFraud.ftc.gov, as advised by the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency. Do not confront the seller yourself.
You Might Also Like
- How to Avoid Buying Stolen Pokemon Cards After a Theft
- Why Did PSA Pokemon TCG Grading Prices Just Increase?
- What Pokemon TCG Sets From 2026 Are Worth Grading Now?