For bulk, Troll and Toad pays the most of the tracked December buyers, at $27 cash per 1,000 Near Mint commons, uncommons and trainers. For singles, Knight and Day Games lists the highest rate at about 60% cash or up to 80% store credit. A buylist is a store's published offer sheet for cards you mail in. PokeInsider reports holiday gift buying often lifts prices in November and December, then adds supply after Christmas.
Table of Contents
- Which bulk buyer pays the most?
- Cash or credit: which singles rate wins?
- When does selling yourself pay more?
- When in December should you sell?
Which bulk buyer pays the most?
According to the Underpriced Editorial Team, Troll and Toad's Pokemon bulk buylist paid $27 cash per 1,000 Near Mint commons, uncommons and trainers bulk seller roundup. Sellers could take 10% more as trade-in credit instead of cash.
By contrast, the MyCardRips Team reports Knight and Day Games pays about $20 per 1,000 commons Pokemon seller guide. That gap makes Troll and Toad the stronger pick for sorted bulk. Bulk means low-value duplicates, so condition and sorting decide whether your lot qualifies.
Cash or credit: which singles rate wins?
The MyCardRips Team reports Knight and Day Games pays about 60% cash or up to 80% store credit for singles. CoolStuffInc states it pays by check, PayPal, or store credit, with 25% extra for store credit current sell list.
Take cash if you want money out now. Take credit only if you plan to buy more cards from that same store. Credit boosts look large, but they lock value to one shop.
When does selling yourself pay more?
TCGplayer Help states marketplace sellers pay 10.75% commission plus 2.5% plus $0.30 per order. That cut leaves you below list price, but the net often exceeds wholesale buylist offers.
The MyCardRips Team ranks TCGplayer first for modern raw singles under $500 and eBay first for vintage or graded cards. That split gives a simple rule:.
- Modern raw single under $500 and you can list and ship it – try TCGplayer first.
- Vintage card or graded slab – try eBay first.
- Need fast cash with no listing work – accept a buylist.
When in December should you sell?
PokeInsider reports holiday gift buying typically lifts Pokemon prices 10-20% in November-December December market report. PokeInsider also reports 15-25% corrections in January-February as recipients resell unwanted cards. PokeInsider reports premium values fell sharply Dec.
21-28, 2025 as gift liquidation raised supply. Waiting until after Christmas risks a lower quote. Card Kingdom states sell orders must be postmarked within 7 days, with grading done 1-5 business days after receipt. Mail early in December so your cards arrive while holiday demand still supports prices.
You Might Also Like
- Vintage Pokemon Cards Outperform Bitcoin and Gold This Year
- Storing Pokemon TCG Tins: Humidity, Light, Crushing, and Insurance
- Storing Pokemon TCG Blister Packs: Humidity, Light, Crushing, and Insurance