Verified Auction Sales · PSA Population Data · Updated Monthly · Editorial Policy
Bar chart of the seller fee on an example $1,000 fixed-price Pokemon card sale: eBay $132.90 with no Store, $123.90 with a Basic Store, Alt $90.00 at the Base tier; Card Ladder does not sell cards

Alt vs Card Ladder vs eBay: Prices, Fees and Where to Sell Pokemon Cards

by

Alt vs Card Ladder vs eBay is not a race between three versions of one service, because they are three different kinds of tool. eBay is a marketplace: you list cards you hold and ship them when they sell. Alt is a marketplace built around the Alt Vault in Delaware, and it publishes a free price estimate called Alt Value. Card Ladder, owned by PSA’s parent company Collectors, is a tool for price data and collection tracking, and you cannot sell a card through it. So the comparison splits into two questions with different answers: which price to trust, and where to sell.

As of October 9, 2026: eBay charges 13.25% on Pokemon singles, counted on the whole sale up to $7,500, and adds $0.40 to any order over $10.00. Alt’s Base-tier fixed-price fee is 14% below $250 and 9% from $250 to $7,499, and its auctions charge sellers nothing while buyers pay a 20% premium. Card Ladder Pro costs $20 monthly or $200 yearly, a full sold-price history on Alt runs $15 a month, and eBay’s sold search and Price Guide are free. Alt’s listings have not been cross-posted to eBay since early April 2026.

Alt vs Card Ladder vs eBay: the master comparison table

Read October 9, 2026, from each company’s own pages.

eBay Alt Card Ladder
What it is Marketplace: auctions, Buy It Now and eBay Live Marketplace plus vault plus the Alt Value estimate Price-data and collection-tracking tool
Can you sell through it? Yes: raw cards and slabs, shipped from home Yes: slabs from the five graders its help center lists (PSA, BGS, BVG, SGC, CGC), already in its vault; raw cards cannot be listed No: its Terms bar offering goods for sale, and its Shop links out
Seller fee on a fixed-price sale 13.25% of the total up to $7,500, then 2.35%, plus $0.30 or $0.40 per order; Basic Store sellers pay 12.35% to $2,500 Base tier: $1–$249 at 14%, $250–$7,499 at 9%, $7,500–$9,999 at 7%, $10,000 and up at 5% None; nothing to sell
Seller fee at auction Same rates as fixed price None; the seller receives 104% to 115% of the hammer price Not applicable
What the buyer pays The price plus any shipping and sales tax No fee on fixed price (3.3% for card payments); a 20% buyer’s premium at auction Buys on the linked site; Card Ladder says its links add no fees
Price data and its cost Sold search (90 days) and Seller Hub Product research (3 years); the Price Guide (2 years) is free Alt Value free on card pages; full sold history $15 a month Free: indexes and the daily sales recap. Pro ($20 monthly, $200 yearly): CL Value, Sales History, Collection
Payout Daily by default, then 1–3 business days to the bank; $2.00 express option Through Stripe by ACH or to a card: up to 4 business days to Stripe, then 1–2 days; no PayPal Not applicable
Owner eBay Inc., which also bought Goldin in May 2024 Alt Platform, Inc., venture-backed, run by founder and CEO Leore Avidar Collectors (PSA’s parent) since December 2021; operated by Ladder Studios, Inc.

Checking prices: CL Value, Alt Value or eBay sold listings

This section answers which number to trust, whatever you plan to do with the card. None of the estimates is itself a sale.

Card Ladder’s CL Value takes a card’s most recent sale and moves it with the player’s or character’s index, then scores its confidence from 1 to 5 by how recent that sale was. Card Ladder lists its inputs, a long run of platforms that includes eBay, Goldin, Heritage and Alt itself. CL Value, the all-time Sales History and collection tracking need Pro, while anyone can see the indexes and a recap of yesterday’s verified sales for free.

Alt Value is a model estimate, refreshed daily, built from auction houses and marketplaces Alt does not name. It appears without charge on Alt’s card pages with a confidence label, and Alt’s own blog describes the weakest label as “Limited data available. Treat this as a ballpark.” SGC and CGC slabs under $500 get no Alt Value, so a CGC Pokemon slab below that level shows none.

eBay’s own data is the raw material. A sold-listings search reaches back 90 days. Product research in Seller Hub reaches back 3 years and records the price actually paid when a Best Offer was accepted. The Price Guide scanner in the eBay app costs nothing, is limited to US users, handles Pokemon cards in English and Japanese, looks back as far as two years of eBay sales, and blends in the Card Ladder Index. For long-run charts, this site’s card pages, such as the Charizard Base Set Unlimited price history, are built from verified sold listings across eBay, TCGPlayer, Goldin, and Fanatics Collect, and our directory of Pokemon card pricing sites lists more free options.

The two estimates often disagree on the same slab, because each is fed by a different pool of sales and a different formula, and we found no published head-to-head test of them. Alt vs Card Ladder sets the two methods side by side, and our Alt Value explainer walks through checking it against recent sold prices.

Selling: Alt and eBay fees on two example sales

This section is about where to sell, so Card Ladder drops out. The table shows our own worked examples at the published fixed-price rates we read on October 9, 2026, for example sale prices of $100 and $1,000.

Example sale price eBay, no Store eBay, Basic Store Alt, Base tier
$100 Fee $13.65; you keep $86.35 Fee $12.75 Fee $14.00; you keep $86.00
$1,000 Fee $132.90; you keep $867.10 Fee $123.90 Fee $90.00; you keep $910.00

The examples leave out costs on both sides. eBay figures its percentage on the buyer’s postage and sales tax too, so real eBay fees run higher than shown; a Basic Store subscription adds $27.95 per month if renewed monthly, and Promoted Listings cost extra. On the Alt side, the examples ignore shipping the card to the vault, Rewards tiers above Base, outtake fees and the 3.3% Alt adds when a buyer pays by card. Both schedules have history. eBay’s February 14, 2025 increase skipped the card rate, which stayed at 13.25%. Alt reworked its schedule in 2025: in January 2025 its help center still put any fixed-price sale up to $7,499 in a 10% tier, so the Base rate under $250 has since risen and the rate from $250 to $7,499 has dropped a point.

Auctions differ more. eBay charges the same percentage on an auction as on a fixed-price sale. Alt charges the auction seller nothing and pays the seller between 104% and 115% of the hammer price, set by the lot’s value and the seller’s Rewards tier, while the winning bidder pays a 20% premium on top. Our Alt vs eBay selling comparison runs more examples, including auctions; the eBay seller’s guide for Pokemon cards explains holds and tax forms; and how to sell Pokemon cards covers the basics of any listing.

Reasons to sell on Alt, and reasons not to

What draws sellers to Alt

  • A lower fee on mid-priced slabs. At the Base tier, 9% from $250 to $7,499, against eBay’s 13.25% plus the order fee; Alt came out cheaper in our $1,000 example.
  • No seller commission at auction. The buyer’s 20% premium funds a seller payout of at least 104% of the hammer price.
  • Cash up front. Put a card or lot that Alt values at $250 or more into an auction, and Alt can advance part of the expected price; Snap to Sell quotes up to 70% of Alt’s valuation.
  • No returns and no packing per sale. Alt treats sales as final and the card changes owner inside the vault. Alt adds no sales tax because the vault sits in Delaware.
  • Storage that costs nothing while a card waits for a buyer. Intake is free too, once a slab’s Alt Value reaches $50.

What puts sellers off Alt

  • Slabs only. Alt’s help center names five graders whose slabs are eligible (PSA, BGS, BVG, SGC, CGC), and nothing raw.
  • 14% under $250. In our $100 example Alt’s fee was higher than eBay’s no-Store fee.
  • The vault comes first. A card has to reach the vault and clear intake before it can go on sale, and withdrawing it in its first 90 days there costs 3% of its Alt Value.
  • A smaller market. Collectors spent nearly $13.7 million on cards at Alt in December 2025, cllct reported from Card Ladder’s data; eBay took more than $297 million.
  • Contract terms to read first. Alt’s Terms dated August 12, 2025 take a security interest over what you store and do not oblige Alt to insure it.
  • Stripe-only payouts. Alt does not support PayPal.

Reasons to sell on eBay, and reasons not to

What draws sellers to eBay

  • The biggest audience. In the same cllct report, eBay led every card marketplace in December 2025 by a wide margin.
  • Any card, from home. Raw cards, cheap singles and slabs all sell, with no vault step and no intake fee.
  • Authenticity Guarantee from $200. PSA inspects eligible singles before the buyer gets them, eBay pays for the check, and eBay says the program protects sellers against fraudulent returns. eBay lowered the threshold from $250 in an announcement made about two months before we read it.
  • Cheaper lanes for some sellers. With a Basic Store the card rate is 12.35% to $2,500, then 2.35%. eBay Live takes a 6% commission, never more than $100 an item, with 2.9% and $0.30 added for processing payments.
  • Flexible payouts. Daily by default, or a $2.00 express payout to a linked debit card or bank account.

What puts sellers off eBay

  • A bigger fee base. The 13.25% applies to shipping and sales tax as well as the price, plus $0.30 or $0.40 per order, and it made eBay the costlier option in our $1,000 example.
  • Return risk survives a no-returns policy. A buyer can still return a card that differs from its listing, with the seller paying return postage, though trading cards sold with no return policy give the buyer only 3 calendar days after delivery to ask.
  • New-seller holds. A new private seller shipping without tracking can wait 31 days after payment for the money.
  • An extra leg for $200-plus singles. Postage to PSA is the seller’s cost, and eBay warns that some Authenticity Guarantee orders run 7 days or more late.
  • The vault now belongs to PSA. eBay sold its vault to PSA in 2024, and a vaulted card now sells on eBay through PSA consignment; that route is laid out in Alt Vault vs PSA Vault.

Why selling on Card Ladder is not an option

Card Ladder has no listing tool, and its own documents explain why. PSA’s announcement of the purchase, dated December 2, 2021, described it as “an industry-leading price guide and market analysis tool for sports cards.” Its Terms of Use, issued by Ladder Studios, Inc., state that “The Content is for informational purposes only” and list among prohibited uses: “Use the Site or Content to advertise or offer to sell or buy any goods or services without LSI’s prior express written consent.”

Its Shop tab is a window onto other sites rather than a store. Card Ladder pitches it as a place to “Browse card listings and auctions across the most popular selling platforms,” and the archived copy we read showed eBay auctions, bought on eBay. Card Ladder discloses “affiliate links to the following marketplaces: eBay, PWCC, and MySlabs” and says buying after clicking one “may result in compensation for Card Ladder.” It also says shoppers pay nothing extra for using its links.

Card Ladder still reaches sellers indirectly: GameStop’s Power Packs, run with PSA, use Card Ladder values to set Instant Buyback offers. PSA’s Collectors Club Premium membership, $199 a year, includes Pro as well. Our Card Ladder review covers whether the free tier is enough for you.

Is Alt reliable? The short version

Alt is a real, operating business. Alt Platform, Inc. is run by its founder and CEO, Leore Avidar, who held that title in an April 2026 press release, and TechCrunch reported $106 million of venture funding raised as of July 2022. The points worth weighing are in its paperwork. Alt’s help center says “Alt does not assert ownership rights over any assets deposited into the Vault” and that stored cards carry insurance up to their Alt Value, while Alt’s August 12, 2025 Terms of Service give it a security interest in stored property and describe insurance as something Alt “may choose to maintain or not maintain in our sole discretion.” On reputation, Alt’s iPhone app is rated 4.9 out of 5 across 15K ratings, and BBB rated Alt F, giving its reason as a failure to respond to 8 complaints.

Custody is a smaller question on eBay, where a card goes from seller to buyer, through PSA for Authenticity Guarantee items, unless you choose the PSA Vault; Card Ladder never handles cards at all. Our full look at whether Alt is legit sets out Alt’s documents, complaint themes and court record with dates.

Which one fits which collector

These are fits, not recommendations.

  • Raw cards or cheap singles: eBay is the only one of the three where a raw card can be listed, and Alt’s 14% band covers every sale under $250.
  • A PSA or CGC slab between $250 and $7,499 that you are happy to vault: Alt’s 9% Base rate sits well below eBay’s no-Store 13.25% in that band.
  • Expensive slabs sold often: an eBay Basic Store’s rate drops to 2.35% past $2,500, so on a big enough slab it can undercut Alt’s Base tier; the Alt vs eBay comparison linked above runs the numbers.
  • Cash before the auction closes: Alt’s auction cash advances are the only pre-sale money among the three.
  • A few price checks a month: eBay’s sold search and Price Guide, Alt Value on Alt’s card pages and this site’s price histories cost nothing.
  • A large graded collection tracked daily, with price alerts: Card Ladder Pro ($20 monthly or $200 yearly), or a $199-a-year PSA Collectors Club Premium membership that bundles it.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between Alt, Card Ladder and eBay?

eBay is a marketplace for raw and graded cards shipped from home. Alt is a marketplace for graded slabs kept in its Delaware vault, and it also publishes a free estimate called Alt Value. Card Ladder, which belongs to Collectors (PSA’s parent), tracks prices and collections and has no way to sell a card.

Can you sell Pokemon cards on Card Ladder?

No. Card Ladder’s Terms of Use describe its content as informational only and forbid advertising or offering goods through the site unless Ladder Studios agrees in writing. Its Shop tab sends you to listings on other platforms, and Card Ladder can earn affiliate money when you buy there.

Is it cheaper to sell a Pokemon card on Alt or on eBay?

It depends on the price. In our worked examples using fees read October 9, 2026, a $100 fixed-price sale costs $13.65 on eBay without a Store and $14.00 at Alt’s Base tier, while a $1,000 sale costs $132.90 on eBay and $90.00 on Alt. eBay also charges its percentage on shipping and sales tax, which the examples leave out.

Which price should I trust: Alt Value, CL Value or eBay sold listings?

Sold listings are actual sales; Alt Value and CL Value are estimates built from sales. Alt Value is free on Alt card pages, CL Value needs Card Ladder Pro, and eBay’s sold search and Price Guide are free. Check any estimate against recent sales of the same card, grade and grader.

How much does Card Ladder Pro cost?

On October 9, 2026 Card Ladder’s pricing page showed $20 per month, or $200 billed annually, after a 7-day trial. Card Ladder Pro also comes with PSA’s Collectors Club Premium membership, which costs $199 a year.

Is Alt a legitimate company?

It is a real, operating company: Alt Platform, Inc., run by founder and CEO Leore Avidar and backed by venture investors. Its Terms take a security interest over stored cards and do not require Alt to carry insurance on them, and BBB rated it F for not responding to 8 complaints. Our separate article on whether Alt is legit covers the full record.

Sources

Fees, features and policies are quoted from each company’s own pages on the date shown and change often, so check the platform’s current terms before you list or subscribe. This article is collector information, not investment, tax or legal advice. Pokémon is a trademark of Nintendo, Creatures Inc. and GAME FREAK inc. Pokemon Pricing is not affiliated with Alt, Card Ladder, Collectors (PSA) or eBay, and earns nothing from any of them.

Owed money from a settlement? Check what is open at OpenClassActions.com. Caring for someone with dementia? Find practical guides at HelpDementia.com. Working out a skin routine? Evidence-based answers at AcneAdvocate.com. Forgot the name of a movie? Identify it at FindThisMovie.com. Was your data exposed? Track active breaches at DataBreachRadar.com.

We use cookies to run this site, measure how it’s used, and show ads. Choose “Essentials only” to limit cookies to what the site needs to work. Privacy Policy. Cookie Policy.