When comparing PSA, CGC, and Beckett (BGS) for Pokémon card grading, PSA is generally considered the industry leader and most widely trusted, especially for Pokémon cards. PSA offers a grading scale from 1 to 10, with 10 representing a pristine card under 10x magnification. Their turnaround time ranges from about 2 to 12 weeks, with fees varying from $20 to over $200 depending on the card’s value and service speed. PSA is known for its broad grading services across many card types, including Pokémon, and has the largest market share, grading nearly 2 million cards in October 2025 alone[1][2][3].
Beckett Grading Services (BGS) is also highly respected, particularly for its detailed subgrading system that evaluates centering, edges, corners, and surface separately. This can provide a more nuanced condition report than PSA’s single grade. BGS grading fees typically range from $30 to $150+, with turnaround times of 3 to 8 weeks. Beckett is favored by collectors who want detailed condition insights and is known for grading sports cards as well as Pokémon[1][2][3].
CGC, originally known for comic book grading, entered the trading card market and gained traction with Pokémon cards. However, since mid-2023, CGC’s grading standards have changed, leading to inconsistencies such as saturation issues and averaging scores that differ from previous practices. This has caused some collectors to view CGC’s top grades as less reliable or less “perfect” compared to PSA’s highest grades, impacting market value. CGC’s turnaround can be long (up to 65 business days), but expedited options exist at higher fees. Despite these challenges, CGC has increased its grading volume significantly, grading over half a million cards in October 2025[1][3].
Key differences between the three grading companies include:
– **Grading Scale and Detail**: PSA uses a single numeric grade (1-10), BGS uses a numeric grade plus four subgrades, and CGC uses a numeric grade but has faced criticism for recent grading standard changes.
– **Market Trust and Value**: PSA grades generally command the highest market prices due to their long-standing reputation and consistency. BGS’s detailed subgrades appeal to collectors wanting more condition transparency. CGC’s recent grading changes have led to some market skepticism.
– **Turnaround Time and Cost**: PSA’s turnaround is typically 2-12 weeks with fees from $20 to $200+, BGS is 3-8 weeks with similar fees, and CGC can take up to 65 business days unless paying for expedited service.
– **Volume and Popularity**: PSA is the largest grader by volume, followed by CGC and then Beckett, reflecting their market share and collector preference[1][2][3].
For collectors and investors, choosing between PSA, BGS, and CGC depends on priorities such as market value, grading detail, turnaround time, and trust in grading consistency. PSA remains the dominant choice for Pokémon cards due to its reputation and market influence, while BGS offers more detailed grading for those who want it. CGC is a growing player but currently faces some challenges in grading consistency that affect collector confidence.
No medical claims or references are involved in this topic, so no authoritative medical sources are applicable here.
